G2 Vendor Directory

SurePayroll vs. OnPay

A side-by-side comparison based on G2 review data.

MetricSurePayroll

by Paychex Inc

OnPay

by OnPay, Inc.

Overall rating4.34.8
Review count542422
Ease of use9.19.7
Ease of setup9.09.5
Quality of support8.89.6
Meets requirements9.09.8
NPS63.97748690.865385
Small Business91.6%97.4%
Mid-Market4.5%2.6%
Enterprise3.9%0.0%
Total page views8061,097
Total LLM citations4,43412,610

SurePayroll

SurePayroll® By Paychex is online payroll software for small business owners, household employers, and accountants who run payroll for clients. It’s built for the owner paying themselves, the owner making a first hire, and every hire after that. SurePayroll is a Paychex company. Paychex, Inc. is one of the largest payroll and HR companies in the United States, and SurePayroll is purpose-built for small business: the payroll capability owners need, without the enterprise features they’d never use.

Pros

  • Payroll
  • Customer Support
  • Ease of Use
  • Payroll Ease
  • Simple
  • Easy Setup

OnPay

OnPay is designed for business owners who want to spend more time running their business — and less time managing back-office tasks. This award-winning payroll and HR software helps small and mid-sized businesses save over 15 hours each month by automating time-consuming processes and simplifying workforce management. “It’s an easy, quick, mobile-friendly system that doesn’t require a steep learning curve,” according to Entrepreneur, and it is rated “Excellent” by PCMag.

Pros

  • Customer Support
  • Ease of Use
  • Payroll
  • Helpful
  • Payroll Ease
  • Onboarding