G2 Vendor Directory

ADP Comprehensive Services vs. Workday Benefits

A side-by-side comparison based on G2 review data.

MetricADP Comprehensive Services

by ADP

Workday Benefits

by Workday

Overall rating4.34.2
Review count176205
Ease of use8.98.6
Ease of setup8.38.2
Quality of support8.68.8
Meets requirements9.09.1
NPS52.02312147.282609
Small Business19.6%5.4%
Mid-Market67.5%24.9%
Enterprise12.9%69.8%
Total page views1,346284
Total LLM citations3,7951,250

ADP Comprehensive Services

ADP Comprehensive Services provides managed HR and payroll services to businesses of all sizes through the support of a team of committed professionals, trusted workflows and best practices and all-in-one technology within the ADP Workforce Now platform for your HR, talent management, benefits administration and payroll tasks. With ADP Comprehensive Services, you get outsourced execution centered around strategic guidance from a designated team of pros.

Pros

  • Helpful
  • Ease of Use
  • Customer Support
  • Payroll Management
  • Payroll Ease
  • Payroll

Workday Benefits

Workday Benefits provides administrators with unparalleled flexibility and control, to easily design and update global benefits plans with effective-date changes. It acts as a single source for all data, seamlessly integrating with core HR to automate benefits rollout and instantly reflect employee status changes without manual re-entry. Workday offers robust compliance support for regulations like ACA, eliminating the need for complex integrations, manual calculations, or form generation. This significantly reduces administrative burden and ensures accuracy.

Pros

  • Ease of Use
  • Simple
  • Organization
  • Customizability
  • Easy Access
  • Intuitive