G2 Vendor Directory

aTalent TM vs. Windmill

A side-by-side comparison based on G2 review data.

MetricaTalent TM

by aTalent

Windmill

by Windmill

Overall rating4.54.6
Review count1130
Ease of use8.79.5
Ease of setup8.79.6
Quality of support9.39.8
Meets requirements9.99.4
NPS81.81818276.666667
Small Business0.0%33.3%
Mid-Market54.5%66.7%
Enterprise45.5%0.0%
Total page views17418
Total LLM citations01,446

aTalent TM

aTalent TM covers the full talent management suite including Onboard, Performance Management, 360 Degree Feedback, Skills & Competency, Talent Review, Succession, Learning & Development and Talent Marketplace. aTalent puts customers at the center of our products, leading to an NPS score of 65+. aTalent serves clients with operations in 30 different countries and more than 1,000,000 employees.We have worked with prestigious multinational and local enterprises, including HG, BMW, Shangri-la, Jabil, Tourism Australia, B/S/H, Vector, TK Elevator, DHL, TDK, and Swire Coca-Cola.

Pros

  • Goal Setting
  • Customer Support
  • Ease of Use
  • Time-saving
  • Progress Tracking
  • Integrations

Windmill

Windmill is the first performance review system people actually like. Powered by AI, it synthesizes all your 1:1 conversations, project work, and feedback throughout the year into reviews that write themselves. Employees respond to quick prompts in Slack instead of staring at blank forms trying to remember six months back. Managers walk in with the full story. HR finally has a process that doesn't need constant nudging. Companies using Windmill cut down time by 83% per cycle time and report 93% employee satisfaction with the process.

Pros

  • 1:1 Management
  • Ease of Use
  • Regular Updates
  • Automation Features
  • Progress Tracking
  • Time Efficiency