G2 Vendor Directory

Guardian vs. Lumana

A side-by-side comparison based on G2 review data.

MetricGuardian

by Alert Enterprise

Lumana

by Lumana

Overall rating4.24.8
Review count6828
Ease of use8.69.8
Ease of setup8.49.7
Quality of support9.29.6
Meets requirements8.99.8
NPS51.61290385.185185
Small Business7.4%47.6%
Mid-Market7.4%33.3%
Enterprise85.3%19.0%
Total page views2,3752,089
Total LLM citations1,4244,224

Guardian

Alert Enterprise Guardian is a leading Physical Identity and Access Management (PIAM), Visitor Management, and Identity & Access Management (IAM) platform that unifies physical security, identity governance, and physical access control systems (PACS) into a single, automated solution. Guardian provides a single pane of glass to manage access for employees, contractors, and visitors, helping organizations reduce manual effort, automate workflows, improve compliance, and gain real-time visibility across facilities.

Pros

  • Ease of Use
  • Customer Support
  • Access Control
  • Reliability
  • Integrations
  • Features

Lumana

Lumana is an AI video security platform that helps security, IT, safety, and operations teams monitor, investigate, and respond to activity across their physical sites automatically. Founded to close the gap between the cameras organizations already run and the intelligence those cameras could provide, Lumana serves enterprise, mid-market, and SLED (state, local, and education) customers across retail, education, healthcare, government, hospitality, manufacturing, and logistics.

Pros

  • Alert Notifications
  • AI Technology
  • Artificial Intelligence
  • Ease of Use
  • Efficiency
  • Notifications