G2 Vendor Directory

Windmill vs. PerformYard Performance Management

A side-by-side comparison based on G2 review data.

MetricWindmill

by Windmill

PerformYard Performance Management

by PerformYard

Overall rating4.64.7
Review count301,261
Ease of use9.59.4
Ease of setup9.69.2
Quality of support9.89.6
Meets requirements9.49.4
NPS76.66666786.709367
Small Business33.3%22.8%
Mid-Market66.7%69.7%
Enterprise0.0%7.5%
Total page views4182,961
Total LLM citations1,44615,943

Windmill

Windmill is the first performance review system people actually like. Powered by AI, it synthesizes all your 1:1 conversations, project work, and feedback throughout the year into reviews that write themselves. Employees respond to quick prompts in Slack instead of staring at blank forms trying to remember six months back. Managers walk in with the full story. HR finally has a process that doesn't need constant nudging. Companies using Windmill cut down time by 83% per cycle time and report 93% employee satisfaction with the process.

Pros

  • 1:1 Management
  • Ease of Use
  • Regular Updates
  • Automation Features
  • Progress Tracking
  • Time Efficiency

PerformYard Performance Management

PerformYard is one platform for employee performance management and development, built for HR teams that want flexibility without complexity. The performance foundation covers review cycles of any shape (annual, quarterly, project-based, 360-degree, probation, performance improvement plans), custom forms and rating scales, cascading goals and OKRs, continuous feedback and recognition, structured 1:1 meetings, anonymous engagement surveys, and reporting through live dashboards, 9-box grids, and trend analysis. PerformYard Development turns that data into decisions.

Pros

  • Ease of Use
  • Goal Setting
  • Helpful
  • Simple
  • Goal Tracking
  • Customer Support