G2 Vendor Directory

Propeller vs. Big Cartel

A side-by-side comparison based on G2 review data.

MetricPropeller

by Propeller Commerce

Big Cartel

by Big Cartel

Overall rating4.54.6
Review count10103
Ease of use8.49.4
Ease of setup8.49.4
Quality of support8.78.5
Meets requirements8.98.8
NPS6073
Small Business40.0%93.2%
Mid-Market60.0%3.9%
Enterprise0.0%2.9%
Total page views53424
Total LLM citations796,047

Propeller

Propeller is a sales-first platform that unifies all B2B sales channels and commercial data to drive AI-powered revenue growth. Most B2B companies don’t have a channel problem — they have a commercial system problem. Sales teams operate in one silo, while product, pricing, and customer data live in others. This fragmentation kills scale, introduces margin leakage, and makes AI unworkable. Propeller fixes that by giving sales teams one platform to manage every channel, every customer, and every deal — with pricing logic, product data, and account context all in one place.

Pros

  • Plugin Flexibility
  • Online Sales
  • E-commerce Services
  • Customizability
  • Easy Integration
  • Flexibility

Big Cartel

Big Cartel is an e-commerce platform for independent creators, artists, makers, and brands. Since 2005, Big Cartel has helped people from all over the world open an online shop and sell over $3.5 billion of their work and keep more of what they earn. Sell physical, digital, print on demand, and subscription products all with 0% transaction fees.

Pros