G2 Vendor Directory

Picnic vs. Open Loyalty

A side-by-side comparison based on G2 review data.

MetricPicnic

by PUG Interactive

Open Loyalty

by Open Loyalty

Overall rating4.44.7
Review count1116
Ease of use9.18.9
Ease of setup10.08.9
Quality of support8.99.7
Meets requirements9.79.0
NPS72.72727381.25
Small Business54.5%28.6%
Mid-Market27.3%71.4%
Enterprise18.2%0.0%
Total page views105203
Total LLM citations1471,119

Picnic

PUG Interactive's Picnic delivers the world's most sophisticated enterprise gamified engagement & loyalty solutions. Designed by former Disney, Microsoft, EA, SAP experts in business, gamification, and technology, Picnic has been the 1# high-performance solution since 2008 for recognition, loyalty, engagement. Promote customers up customer pyramid tiers to maximize lifetime value and profitability. Integrates with enterprise tech stacks, CRMs, data warehouses, CMSs, POSs, etc.

Pros

    Open Loyalty

    Open Loyalty is your enterprise loyalty technology partner, focused on growing CLV and Profit Margin through a gamified loyalty engine, API-first technology, and loyalty program expertise drawn from 100+ successfully implemented loyalty programs - helping you build lasting customer habits, not just short-term sales spikes. Every year, Open Loyalty helps generate $4B+ in revenue through gamified loyalty programs.

    Pros

    • Loyalty Programs
    • Features
    • Customer Support
    • Easy Integrations
    • Sales Growth
    • Ease of Use