G2 Vendor Directory

Pencil vs. Mermaid

A side-by-side comparison based on G2 review data.

MetricPencil

by Pencil Project

Mermaid

by Mermaid

Overall rating4.04.7
Review count2017
Ease of use8.79.2
Ease of setup9.59.5
Quality of support7.48.7
Meets requirements8.48.9
NPS3588.235294
Small Business65.0%43.8%
Mid-Market25.0%31.3%
Enterprise10.0%25.0%
Total page views109761
Total LLM citations1,011111

Pencil

An open-source GUI prototyping tool that's available for ALL platforms.

Pros

    Mermaid

    Mermaid is a diagramming tool built on Mermaid.js, the open-source diagramming library. Diagrams are defined as text in Mermaid syntax, and the rendering engine determines the layout. When a process changes, updating the diagram is a text edit rather than a rebuild — the practical difference from drag-and-drop editors, where repositioning nodes is part of every revision.

    Pros

    • Ease of Use
    • Simple
    • Integrations
    • Efficiency Optimization
    • Easy Drawing
    • Drag